Manea's "The Trenchcoat"

Norman Manea's "The Trenchcoat" was a very interesting read. I did feel a bit lost while reading it, until I realized it was not about the details of the story that mattered. Once I adjusted the way I was reading it, the story became much more enjoyable. It felt very distant and impersonal for quite a bit of the text. It focused quite a bit on interpersonal relationships, with the use of symbolism to describe life at that time in Communist Romania. A lot of the story involves reading between the lines of the text to be able to understand the underlying messages. 

While not explicitly mentioned within the book, the novel describes life under Communist Romanian President Nicolae Ceaușescu. Ceaușescu was famously executed along with his wife on Christmas Day, ending communism in Romania. Manea is able to paint the scenes of the story through symbolism. Much of what he writes throughout the story has double meanings and plays into a larger picture. He was unable to explicitly mention specific people or parties to ensure his safety and that of his family. I did not realize that so much of the story would depend on understanding some of Romania's history. Luckily, going into the novel I had the past knowledge necessary to understand the timing of the story. 

I think that a lot of the importance of this story is how it can impact people. Sadly, there are many countries with improper rulers and unfair laws. There is a universality to the text that can still be utilized and compared to the world today. Bad governance has been prevalent all throughout history and modern times. 

Throughout the dinner party, I kept asking myself: what am I missing? It felt very mundane and uncomfortable and I was unable to see the significance of it. I am open to hearing anyone's interpretations of that scene as I would like to know how other people understood it. 

I really enjoyed Manea's writing style. I've began wondering if his other novels are similar to this one. Do they all convey political undertones? How have they impacted the lives of those who have read it? Furthermore, how does it represent Romanian beliefs and social circumstances during that time? 

My question to the class is: What do you think the purpose of the dinner was? Were there secret messages or was it to set the scene of the mysterious trench coat?



Comments

  1. Michael Liudeng16 March 2022 at 19:49

    Hi Madi! I really enjoyed reading your thoughts on The Trenchcoat. Your question was pretty interesting; I didn't think a lot about the purpose of the dinner at all; it just felt like a small disturbance in a monotonous life that was worth highlighting. In a sense, it did set the scene for the trenchcoat, but only because it almost felt like there didn't need to be some ulterior motive for me, and it just seemed to blend in with the stagnation of the guests' life until the trenchcoat appeared.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Aquila17 March 2022 at 00:06

    hey Madi! It was great to read your thoughts on the story. I think your question and thoughts on the dinner party were interesting because they were the opposite of how I felt. Well, it was very mundane and boring which can't be contested, but I found it a very integral part of the story (though maybe this was just me). I felt as if the dinner party kind of laid the scene fot the rest of the story. The uneasiness and mundanity you mentioned really emphasised the regime in Romania at the time, and how everyone was forced to live the same and weren't allowed to argue but of course there were still things going on that no one could safely talk about. The way that everyone acted how they were "supposed" to act during the dinner party, but not how they actually felt, showed that there is a lot more below the surface in the rest of the text; and by extension in Romania during a time of drastic change.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Unknown17 March 2022 at 01:33

    Thank you for sharing your thoughts!
    In my opinion, I think the awkwardness and mundaneness of the dinner party kind of sets a tone for the novel as well as setting up the appearance of the trenchcoat. It was full of unspoken tension and discomfort, which is what I assumed living in communist Romania could have felt like.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Unknown17 March 2022 at 07:49

    Hi Madi,

    Thank you for sharing your insights. I feel like the party was a way for readers to have a brief characterization of the characters and to set the tone/setting for the rest of the book. You mentioned the mundaneness of it. Doesn't it sound fun to go to a party where the most exciting thing to come out of it is that someone forgot their jacket?

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Georges Perec

Georges Perec's W, or the Memory of Childhood is a very interesting way of illustrating trauma. It had an unexpected and unnerving storyline. It was a semi-autobiographical work of post-modernist literature. One half of the story is fictional and follows a utopian olympic whilst the other is constructed of real childhood memories. The main character adapts the identity of Winkler to evade military service. The second part follows a mythical Olympics hosted on an island where the winners are idolized and the losers are tortured. At first it was hard to understand how the stories were connected.  I found that this novel had me trying to piece together the story until the third story instalment. The land of W was an escape from the harsh realities of the world during the Holocaust. The island of W was a mirrored reality of what the author was enduring. It was a different type of retelling of the Holocaust. The fact that the island was called W is symbolic of double lives and how the n
Read more

Agostino

The novel Agostino  by Alberto Moravia was an interesting read. I can confidently say that the story was not what I was expecting it to be. When the novel started, I enjoyed reading the story and seeing the progression of the character. It began to confuse me and then shock me with the content of the story. It followed a young Agostino on a vacation with his mother and all of the things that happen to them. The story examines the intricacies and confusion of growing up. He struggles with bullying and being picked on by older boys. He then becomes eager to belong to the group that had previously picked on him. He explores his confusing feelings surrounding his mother as she leaves him alone daily. He feels overprotective and confusing sexual feelings.  Most of the story takes place on the beach and I enjoyed reading that. I like when stories take place in natural environments and can greatly explain the setting of the story. A strong story setting creates a more enjoyable reading experi
Read more

The Shrouded Woman Analysis

 I thought that the narration of the story being told from the perspective of a dead woman was a very interesting take. I have never read a text told that way, through the eyes of the deceased. I enjoy reading stories about romance and loss (of love, of a person) so I enjoyed this read. I've scrolled through my classmates blog posts and it was interesting to see that most of them have also enjoyed this reading the most. There are many things about this story that make it such a beautiful and interesting read. This story feels very intimate and personal, almost as if reading a diary. I found that this made it very enjoyable to read in a way that the other readings were unable to captivate my attention, despite a somewhat similar style. It was beautiful to read how Ana María reflected upon her life, her love and happiness, but also her sadness and regrets. She feels love in both its beauty and its agony. She holds both happiness and resentment in her relationships throughout her life
Read more